Kurt D. Starsinic on Mon, 10 May 1999 15:12:41 -0400 (EDT)


[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: Debian and Red Hat


"Michael W. Ryan" wrote:
> Don't ask me why, but I'm considering trying out Debian.  It's not because
> of any specific dissatisfaction with Red Hat, it's just that I keep
> hearing so many good things about Debian, I figured I should try it out.
> 
> The catch is that I have only a single system at home, and it would not be
> proper for me to use one of my systems at work to try it out.  This means
> that I need to have a functional system at home.  To that end, could
> someone (it can be more than one) OBJECTIVELY compare the features of the
> two distributions.  I tend to see alot more support for RPMs for various
> non-standard packages (XEmacs, WindowMaker, etc.), but I suspect this may
> be because Debian has a more centralized distribution point (a point I
> like, BTW).  For example, will I be able to get Debian packages for
> XEmacs, WindowMaker, Python, etc.?  Please don't point out alien.  I am
> aware of it, but I'd rather use native packages instead of a converted
> package (which depends on the author of alien not missing any subtleties
> of the various packaging schemes).
> 
> I'm not interested in philosophies.  I'm interested in a functioning
> systems.

    I have experience installing and using Slackware, S.u.S.E., RedHat,
and Debian.  Debian is rock solid.  Ease of installation is way up there,
but you may not find it _quite_ as easy as RedHat to install.

    Debian has all the packages that RedHat has, and many more by far.
Its release-to-release upgrades are the most extraordinarily painless
I've ever seen.  Once you've got some version of Debian installed on
a given system, I can imagine very few reasons why you'd ever prefer
any other distrubution:

    1. You've installed a state-of-the-art video card, and there's
       only X support for it in S.u.S.E.

    2. Branding is valuable to you, and you want Red Hat.

    3. There is no #3.

   Peace,
* Kurt Starsinic (Kurt.Starsinic@isinet.com) --------- Technical Specialist *
|  `In very small systems, the idea of something having a meaning becomes   |
|   as vacuous as saying that a brick is a very small house.'               |
|                              - Marvin Minsky                              |
Institute for Scientific Information                   http://www.isinet.com/

--
To unsubscribe, send a message with the word 'unsubscribe' in the subject
or body of your message to plug-request@lists.nothinbut.net