Brian Vagnoni on 2 Mar 2009 19:23:18 -0800

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: [PLUG] Wish list for PLUG talks --> OpenWRT Corrected

Man I've got to proof read better; sorry.

DD-WRT is free for Broadcom wireless chip sets only. You must pay an
activation fee to use the firmware permanently on anything else even
Atheros devices. DD-WRT does ***NOT*** follow typical FOSS ideology. 
In one hand you have Broadcom who have proprietary drivers and code
and the folks at DD-WRT make that firmware available for free. On the
other hand you have Atheros who is working with the FOSS community
building their stuff into the kernel and DD-WRT charges for that.
DD-WRT in the future may include the Realtek wireless chip sets as
part of the no charge version. 

My understanding about the way the folks at DD-WRT see it is that
Broadcom gear is considered residential and therefore no charge, and
anything else is considered PRO gear which they charge for. The problem
is that they aren't charging for support they are charging for 
activation which is where it sticks in the crawl for most
FOSS folks. 
There is quite a lot of bad blood and politics between the DD-WRT,
Sveasoft, and the true ideological FOSS groups. I personally will use
whatever works best for customers or myself in a given situation. It's
like a $25 activation fee if I wanted to use it with say my UBNT
Router Station.
I've also heard claims on some blogs of security issues with DD-WRT.
Though these claims could just be pro-FOSS propaganda. I haven't see
any papers on it, just talk. The politics are very annoying as it's
hard to get to the real truth.

As far as Open-WRT not having a web gui that's not correct. There is
X-WRT and Webif which run on top of Open-WRT. 
Honestly and with regard to the incredible skill level using the Linux
command line I find here on this list I don't see why folks just don't
use Open-WRT. However, if you just want something to plug and play
with your Linksys/Broadcom router and don't care about the politics
DD-WRT is the way to go.
One thing I really like about the 3rd party firmware is being able to
setup a cron job to reboot the wireless router daily; saves on service
calls big time. Most customers I deal with are non-IT so they don't
want to be bothered or billed for any of this stuff. They just want to
focus on their core non-IT business and have the IT tools work for them.  

Brian Vagnoni
PGP Digital Fingerprint
F076 6EEE 06E5 BEEF EBBD  BD36 F29E 850D FC32 3955

Philadelphia Linux Users Group         --
Announcements -
General Discussion  --